No amateur resultsProfessional recordDate | Opponent | Place | Result | 1887 | + Jan. 1 | John Case | United States , United States | KO 5 | + Feb. 2 | Jack Conway | Rock Island, United States | KO 3 | + Mar. 3 | Chris Christopher | Grand Rapids, United States | KO 8 | - Aug. 1 | Andy Bowen | New Orleans, United States | L 3 | 1888 | + July 20 | Joe Johnson | Marion, United States | KO 5 | + Dec. 21 | Dick England | Lake City, United States | KO 23 | 1889 | + Apr. 30 | Martin Shaughnessy | Detroit, United States | KO 23 | + May 27 | Michael Dunn | Grosse Point, United States | KO 9 | + June 18 | Martin Shaughnessy | Grosse Point, United States | KO 48 | + Sept. 3 | Henry Baker | Grand Rapids, United States | KO 3 | = Oct. 10 | Jimmy Murphy | Grand Rapids, United States | Draw 57 | ^ Nov. 20 | Jimmy Murphy | Grand Rapids, United States | Exh 8 | 1890 | + June 6 | Henry Baker | Grand Rapids, United States | KO 3 | + July 20 | John McInerssey | Chicago, United States | KO 5 | + Aug. 4 | Bob Harper | Chicago, United States | KO 4 | + Oct. 5 | Con Doyle | Shelby, United States | TKO 28 | + Nov. 23 | Ed Bartlett | Sheffield, United States | KO 3 | + Dec. 6 | Professor McGuire | Chicago, United States | TKO 3 | + Dec. 6 | Frank Garrard | Chicago, United States | TKO 3 | 1891 | + Feb. 17 | Danny Needham | Minneapolis, United States | TKO 76 | + Aug. 9 | Billy McMillan | Richardson, United States | KO 3 | ^ Sept. 28 | Jim Hall | Chicago, United States | Exh 3 | + Dec. 13 | Frank Howson | Chicago, United States | KO 14 | 1892 | + Apr. 11 | Con Doyle | Dubuque, United States | W 8 | + May 7 | Paddy Brennan | Dubuque, United States | W 10 | + July 30 | Jack Wilkes | South Omaha, United States | TKO 17 | = Nov. 24 | Jack Collins | Detroit, United States | Draw 8 | = Dec. 1 | Tommy Kelly | Detroit, United States | Draw 8 | 1893 | * Apr. 8 | George Dawson | Chicago, United States | ND 6 | = Aug. 29 | Mysterious Billy Smith | Brooklyn, United States | Draw 6 | + Nov. 2 | Harry Jamieson | Waterbury, United States | KO 2 | * Dec. 11 | Joe Guthrie | Naugatuck, United States | NC 3 | 1894 | = Jan. 9 | Mysterious Billy Smith | Boston, United States | Draw 6 | + Apr. 10 | Morris Lane | West Haven, United States | TKO 3 | * Apr. 22 | Harry Wilkes | Saint Louis, United States | NC 5 | + May 22 | Jack Falvey | Hartford, United States | KO 3 | + June 1 | Jack Pitts | Minneapolis, United States | KO 3 | + July 26 | Mysterious Billy Smith | Minneapolis, United States | W 20 | World Welterweight Title | + Sept. 13 | Billy Layton | Saint Joseph, United States | KO 4 | 1895 | + Jan. 18 | Jack Dempsey
| Coney Island, United States | TKO 3 | World Welterweight Title | + Feb. 25 | Shorty Ahearn | Chicago, United States | W 4 | + Mar. 11 | Emmett Mellody | Kansas City, United States | W 4 | * Mar. 20 | Tom Tracey | Chicago, United States | ND 8 | * May 27 | Mysterious Billy Smith | Coney Island, United States | NC 18 | World Welterweight Title | * July 26 | Tom Crawford | Syracuse, United States | ND 4 | * Nov. 18 | Joe Dunfee | Buffalo, United States | ND 3 | 1896 | ^ Jan. 9 | Kid Lavigne | New York, United States | Exh 4 | + Jan. 15 | Henry Baker | Grand Rapids, United States | W 6 | - Mar. 2 | Charles McCoy | Maspeth, United States | KO by 15 | * Mar. 6 | Mysterius Billy Smith | Syracuse, United States | ND 6 | + May 18 | Joe Dunfee | Buffalo, United States | KO 6 | + June 22 | Billy Maber | Buffalo, United States | TKO 9 | + Aug. 20 | Dick Moore | Buffalo, United States | W 20 | + Nov. 25 | Mysterious Billy Smith | Maspeth, United States | WDQ 9 | World Welterweight Title | + Dec. 21 | Billy Professor McCarthy | Buffalo, United States | TKO 7 | + Dec. 23 | Billy Payne | Syracuse, United States | KO 4 | World Welterweight Title | 1897 | + Feb. 24 | Tom Tracey | Syracuse, United States | TKO 9 | World Welterweight Title | + Mar. 17 | Patsy Raedy | Rochester, United States | TKO 18 | + May 10 | Paddy Gorman | Rochester, United States | TKO 3 | + May 24 | Patsy Raedy | Rochester, United States | TKO 6 | + June 21 | Tommy Williams | Syracuse, United States | KO 2 | * Sept. 8 | Charles McCoy | Syracuse, United States | NC 5 | + Nov. 25 | Australian Jimmy Ryan | Elmira, United States | KO 5 | + Nov. 30 | Billy Stift | Chicago, United States | TKO 6 | + Dec. 20 | Bill Heffernan | Buffalo, United States | KO 3 | 1898 | + Feb. 25 | George Green | San Francisco, United States | KO 18 | + June 13 | Tommy West | New York, United States | TKO 14 | World Welterweight Title | + Oct. 24 | Jack Bonner | Brooklyn, United States | W 20 | World Middleweight Title | + Nov. 8 | Jack Bonner | Philadelphia, United States | TKO 6 | + Nov. 23 | Johnny Gorman | Syracuse, United States | TKO 8 | * Dec. 2 | Tommy West | Philadelphia, United States | ND 6 | + Dec. 23 | Dick O'Brien | Hartford, United States | TKO 14 | 1899 | + Mar. 1 | Charley Johnson | Hot Springs, United States | KO 8 | + Mar. 13 | Paddy J. Purtell | Cincinnati, United States | TKO 4 | + Apr. 6 | Frank Dutch Neal | Dubuque, United States | KO 6 | + Apr. 19 | Billy Stift | Davenport, United States | W 20 | + Aug. 31 | Jack Moffat | Dubuque, United States | W 20 | + Sept. 18 | Frank Craig | Brooklyn, United States | TKO 10 | World Middleweight Title | 1900 | + Feb. 2 | George Lawler | Hot Springs, United States | TKO 13 | = May 29 | Charles McCoy | Chicago, United States | Draw 6 | + June 29 | Young Mahoney | Chicago, United States | W 6 | = July 24 | Jack Root | Chicago, United States | Draw 6 | + Nov. 10 | Geoffrey Thorne | Chicago, United States | KO 3 | + Nov. 27 | Kid Carter | Chicago, United States | W 6 | 1901 | + Jan. 17 | Jack Beauscholte | Springfield, United States | KO 3 | + Jan. 31 | Jim Judge | Minneapolis, United States | KO 4 | + Mar. 4 | Tommy West | Louisville, United States | TKO 17 | World Middleweight Title | + Aug. 22 | Bob Douglass | Kansas City, United States | TKO 7 | - Oct. 10 | George Green | Kansas City, United States | LDQ 6 | 1902 | + Jan. 30 | George Green | Kansas City, United States | KO 7 | + Feb. 15 | Jack Beauscholte | Chicago, United States | W 6 | + Feb. 25 | Tim Draffin Murphy | Kansas City, United States | TKO 9 | + Mar. 14 | Mysterious Billy Smith | Kansas City, United States | KO 4 | + Apr. 3 | Billy Stift | Kansas City, United States | W 10 | + May 26 | Jimmy Handler | Kansas City, United States | TKO 4 | + June 24 | Johnny Gorman | Covent Garden, Great Britain | KO 3 | World Middleweight Title | + Sept. 15 | Kid Carter | Fort Erie, Canada | KO 6 | World Middleweight Title | + Oct. 3 | Barney Walsh | Kansas City, United States | KO 2 | + Oct. 3 | Jack Beauscholte | Kansas City, United States | KO 3 | 1903 | + Jan. 15 | Billy Stift | Kansas City, United States | KO 4 | + Feb. 3 | Cyclone Kelly | Hot Springs, United States | TKO 7 | + June 1 | James J Walker | Battle Creek, United States | KO 5 | + June 23 | Big Jack Hickey | Battle Creek, United States | KO 4 | + June 30 | John Wille | Butte, United States | KO 4 | 1904 | * Jan. 27 | Philadelphia Jack O'BRIEN | Philadelphia, United States | NC 6 | + Feb. 24 | Jack Beauscholte | Indianapolis, United States | TKO 6 | + Sept. 10 | Frank Garrard | Chicago, United States | KO 3 | + Oct. 10 | Bob Douglass | Saint Louis, United States | KO 4 | + Oct. 26 | Tommy Wallace | Benton Harbor, United States | KO 5 | + Nov. 15 | Jack Graham | South Bend, United States | TKO 4 | * Nov. 23 | Jack Root | Philadelphia, United States | NC 4 | + Dec. 29 | Billy Stift | Benton Harbor, United States | KO 4 | 1905-1906 Inactive | 1907 | + Feb. 5 | Dave Barry | Hot Springs, United States | KO 5 | = Mar. 4 | Hugo Kelly | Charlotte, United States | Draw 6 | ^ Aug. 4 | Battling Nelson | South Bend, United States | Exh 6 | 1908-1910 Inactive | 1911 | - Nov. 29 | Denver Ed Martin | Portland, United States | 6 |
Summary
Total bouts: 112, Won: 88 (73 inside the limit), Lost: 4 (1 inside the limit), Draw: 8, NC: 12
|